“Mine” vs. “Ours” — A Newleywed's Case Study

Posted on September 17, 2008 by Him and tagged guest_post, marriage, relationship, savings

Thewriter lives in Chicago, just got married, and writes about money and writing over at The Writer’s Coin.

For the most part, my new wife and myself have done pretty well when it comes to adjusting to the financial side of married life. We created a joint bank account and the first few months have worked really well — we're living our lives and we're putting away a good amount of money. There have been some hiccups along the way, we aren't the Brady Bunch or anything (nevermind the kids part, that's a whole other ballpark). We've had our fair share of disagreements over things like emergency funds and semantics about targeted savings accounts, but overall we're good.

This past month, something new came up that had us clashing again. It's interesting that such minor things can cause such a lack of understanding between two people that love each other so much. The issue: I get paid twice a month but M gets paid every Friday, which means she'll have four “extra” paychecks over the course of a year. When I got paid every two weeks, I had the same problem and I just treated it like found money — it went straight into my ING savings account.

M, however, didn't see it that way. She would rather have it accounted for throughout the year and taken into full consideration when we budget out how we spend money on a day-to-day basis. This way would give us a bump in the amount of money we have to spend every month. Which is understandable because if you don't count that money, on paper it looks like she's not “contributing” as much to “our” finances (marriage invites the liberal use of quotes and air quotes — get used to it) than she's actually making. So she wanted our budgeting spreadsheet to reflect that money.

I wasn't thinking about that and stressed that this was a great way of saving even more money (me being greedy and cheap). Instead of bringing it into the budget (where it would likely get spent, I've learned), I wanted to shoot it straight into our joint ING account.

Then things got defensive. I kind of understood her point, but I still wanted to “win” the argument, prove I was right and get some extra saving going into our coffers. It wasn't “my” money being accounted for, so what did I care? She could tell and wasn't going to give in easily. It was late and her last attempt to foil me was to say that she would “forget” to transfer new money over on months where there was an extra paycheck. I countered with this jewel: “I'll remind you.”

Now, it was late and we had just gone through our budget, so things were a little tense. So we left it at that and let it soak in for a few days. The next week was an extra paycheck week and I brought it up. We had cooled down a little — I wasn't out to “win” and she wasn't out to stop me from winning. We both realized that, in the end, it's “our money” (there is that beautiful phrase single people dread to hear) and it doesn't matter how we account for it as long as we end up deciding it together and being responsible about it.

The lesson? Money makes us defensive and edgy because what used to be “mine” is no longer. Not just with money, with everything. Sharing isn't easy, especially when it comes to such a contentious thing as money. But that's the lesson learned here — that money, like everything else, is no longer “yours.” When you marry someone everything becomes “ours” and the sooner you realize that, the easier it'll be for you to let this kind of this just roll right off your back.

Comments/Trackbacks

Trackback URL: http://www.makelovenotdebt.com/MT/mlnd-trackbacks.cgi/1270

Laura | Sep 17, 2008

Wonderful post! It's a huge adjustment when you get married and now share accounts.

Reply to this comment

Writer's Coin | Sep 17, 2008

Thanks for the opportunity to guest post and hope the wedding and honeymoon go smoothly!

Reply to this comment

Stock Research | Sep 27, 2008

Great post anyone planning to get married should read. I know a lot of married couples that choose to maintain separate bank accounts and that seems to lead to even more tension than what you're describing above.

Reply to this comment




Have you read our Comment Policy?

At Make Love, Not Debt, we encourage reader participation and constructive criticism, however unfavorable your position may be. In order to keep things civil we have a few ground rules.

To facilitate off-blog discussion and combat comment spam, you are required to provide an email address.

Some HTML is allowed in the post. It is limited to the following: a href, strong, em, ul, li, blockquote

For bold please use the tag <strong></strong> and for italics please use <em></em>. For any HTML usage, please remember to close your tags!

Images are not allowed.

Comments with 3 to 4 links will be moderated. Comments with 5 or more links will be marked as spam.

We DO NOT, under any circumstance, tolerate personal attacks, racism, sexism, or spam. Should we see any of the above posted on our blog, we will take one of the following actions:

  1. If your URL seems spammy but your comment is benign, we will delete the link to your URL and keep the full comment.
  2. Outright spammy comments will be junked, never to be seen.
  3. Offensive comments will either be deleted or disemvowelled.

If you are not comfortable with our comment policy, please do not leave a comment.

Live Comment Preview

Your comment says: